In This ArticleView AllIn This ArticleThe ControversyIs It Dangerous?Nutrition Facts
In This ArticleView All
View All
In This Article
The Controversy
Is It Dangerous?
Nutrition Facts
With social media and apps like TikTok, Instagram, and Facebook, influencers without proper nutrition training have a megaphone to shout their healthy eating advice—and it can be downright confusing, conflicting and nearly impossible to know what to believe. Take canola oil for example. Is it really as bad as some influencers claim it is?
What Is the Best Oil for Cooking?
We tapped a crew of dietitians to clear up the canola oil controversy and asked: Is canola oil really killing us—or are these diet influencers simply poisoning the conversation? Let’s find out.
Getty Images
The Canola Oil Controversy
There are hundreds of videos from “health coaches,” influencers and other public figures touting that canola oil causes morechronic inflammationin the body than sugar and any other processed carbs. “They’re very unstable fats that are rancid before you consume them, then if you cook with them, they get even more rancid as they oxidize and they gunk up their cells,” one TikToker claimed.
We know that chronic inflammation is linked to nearly all of the leading causes of death in America, including heart disease, type 2 diabetes and cancer, as well as autoimmune disorders and joint issues. And since Americans cook with canola oil fairly frequently, at the rate of 2.41 million metric tons per year—which is triple how much we used just two decades ago, according to March 2023 data fromStatistica—this could be a big deal. It could be—if it were actually true.
This muddies the waters, says Caspero, because with the rise of social media, everyone can be considered an “expert” as long as they have a platform. The more controversial and shocking a claim might be, the more shareable it becomes. That’s how the wave becomes a tsunami, and why Jenna A. Werner, RD, creator of Happy Strong Healthy in Middletown, New Jersey, felt compelled to take to social media toset the record straight on Instagram(@happystronghealthy.rd), noting that one food does not determine your health, and using fear-based messaging does not enhance anyone’s health.
“‘Gotcha’ games around food ingredients are very trendy and easily shared, whether they are true or not,” says Caspero.
Is Olive Oil Healthy?
Before we dive into the specifics,Lauren Smith, RD, owner of Lauren’s Balanced Bites, wants to address one thing. “When it comes to analyzing a person’s diet, no one ingredient is inherently harmful unless a person is allergic to it. Social media has unfortunately caused a lot of fear-mongering around foods, canola oil being one of them, and this is not helping anyone.”
Is Canola Oil Dangerous?
As far as these canola oil claims go, Caspero says they’re a lot like the claims about soy and its relationship to cancer risk. “People are confusing animal studies for human trials. Omega-6-rich seed oils have been shown to increase inflammation in rats, not humans. Andsoycauses issues in rats, as they metabolize estrogen differently, but that doesn’t stack up to decades of human trials,” explains Caspero.
When it comes to canola oil specifically, one main claim is that seed oils, including canola oil, spike inflammation in the body based on a theory that omega-6 fatty acids—like the linoleic acid in canola oil—raise arachidonic acid levels in the body. Arachidonic acid is a precursor to several pro-inflammatory mediators, and if this were true, we should see higher levels of inflammation in someone who consumes high levels of linoleic acid.
“None of this is true based on the best evidence that we have today,” says Caspero.
For example, a 2023 randomized controlled trial published inLipidssuggests that no changes were found in arachidonic acid levels in people when linoleic acid intake was reduced.
“Remember, based on the mechanisms proposed, consuming high levels of linoleic acid should increase arachidonic acid levels—which is simply not shown,” says Caspero.
Is Canola Oil Healthy?
A variety of oils—soybean, peanut and rapeseed included—are being shamed for the same reason, saysElizabeth Shaw, M.S., RDN, CPT, anEatingWellcontributor, owner of ShawSimpleSwaps.com and author of theAir Fryer Cookbook for Dummies.While none of these seem to offer the level of heart-health benefits omega-3 fats do—such as olive oil—they can all be part of a healthy diet.
“Every oil in food production has a purpose, with some purposes having higher nutritional value and more supportive health benefits than others,” explains Shaw. “While some oils, like extra-virgin olive oil, have more supportive health qualities than others and should be included more abundantly in the diet, it does not mean canola, peanut, soybean or rapeseed oils do not have a place in a healthy, balanced diet for healthy individuals.”
Canola oil and other seed oils can be better cooking choices than options that are higher in saturated fats, like butter or coconut oil, especially if you’re concerned about your blood cholesterol levels. Swapping outsaturated fatand industrially created trans fats in favor of polyunsaturated fat seed oils decreases bothcholesteroland heart disease risk, adds Caspero.
“Funny enough, most of the people I’ve seen bashing seed oils are very pro-saturated fat,” says Caspero. “Again, this is the opposite of what theAmerican Heart Associationrecommends for heart health and is a big red flag for not understanding the data.”
Canola oil has a low saturated fat content. Instead, seed oils, including canola, have a mix of mono- and polyunsaturated fats that may help reduce the risk of heart disease. Plus they’re very affordable, making them a good choice when you’re watching yourgrocery budget.
“While these videos seem to shame on the refinement process, they neglect the health benefits that have been supported in the research and the affordability oils like this have to help those in various socioeconomic statuses receive healthy fats to improve heart health,” says Shaw.
Canola Oil Nutrition
The following nutrition information is according to the USDA. Keep in mind that oils contain no other nutrients besides calories and fats, so that is the only info we include here. In addition to canola oil, we also include nutrition info for olive oil and butter so you can compare the three.
1-tablespoon serving ofcanola oil:
1 tablespoon ofolive oil:
1 tablespoon ofbutter:
‘It is true that canola oil is higher in omega-6s than omega-3s, but before we call this a bad thing, we need to look at what a diet looks like as a whole and find places to add more omega-3s," says Werner.
The main reason canola oils might be correlated with negative health outcomes is the way they’re utilized. Seed oils are pervasive inultra-processed foodsand are often used to fry foods, as well. It’s less likely that it’s the seed oil causing increased disease risk and more likely the lack of fiber, concentration of sugar and refined carbohydrates in the foods they’re featured in that cause health challenges.
13 Healthy High-Fat Foods You Should be Eating
“If a client comes to me and is eating a large amount of canola oil or a super-high-fat diet in general, we would discuss alternative solutions and options for that person,” says Werner.
All of the dietitians we spoke to agree that most foods are A-OK in moderation.
“I would only recommend stopping use for someone who has a food allergy or sensitivity to the oil,” says Shaw. “With that said, variety is key in a balanced, healthy diet, so be sure to diversify your intake of healthy fats for optimum benefits.”
Focus on quality, diversity andcultural inclusionof foods in a balanced and healthy diet, rather than restricting one specific food, to make your heart happy and your body healthy.
Lastly, about that rancidity detail. Processing alone doesn’t make oils rancid. Canola oil is shelf-stable for about one to two years, and like nearly all foods, it will eventually go bad, especially when exposed to high heat and light, explains Caspero. You will know canola oil has gone bad when it smells off or is tacky in texture.
The Bottom Line
In conclusion, Shaw says it best. “What I tell my followers and friends when they come to me confused about information like this is quite simple. Eat a variety-filled diet and you don’t need to worry about any one food or ingredient making or breaking your health. Before taking the advice of an influencer on TikTok, remember that there are credentialed healthcare professionals here to serve you and offer you sound, science-based advice.”
Many insurance companies will pay for you to see a registered dietitian. If your insurance covers this service, take advantage of it so that you can bust any nutrition myths you may have questions about and ensure your diet is balanced and varied so you’re getting the right balance of nutrients for overall good health and to help treat or prevent specific conditions.
Was this page helpful?Thanks for your feedback!Tell us why!OtherSubmit
Was this page helpful?
Thanks for your feedback!
Tell us why!OtherSubmit
Tell us why!
